Unfortunately, looking back on it, I would have to disagree with Wikipedia's pre-episode preview, labeling "Follow the Leader" as a Richard-centric episode...
Anyway, in anticipation for the two-hour LOST finale, "The Incident" -- YES!!! -- let's consider the major death which is said to occur... My initial guess after having learned of this development several weeks ago? Juliet. No questions asked...but now, well, you'll just have to read my LOST Theory/Mythology section down below. :)
Welp, on to a brief episode synopsis.
- Let's start off with 1977, first with Sawyer and the gang who were making their way to the beaches. As we saw last week, Sawyer and Juliet were caught, while Miles and Hurley and Jin escaped. Miles, Hurley, and Jin make preparations to leave, packing some food, etc. Dr. Pierre Chang notices them leaving and, after asking Hurley a few questions, gets them to admit that they are, indeed, from the future. He ascertains that Miles is, in fact, his grown-up son. Miles takes this opportunity to warn Dr. Chang that he must send everyone off of the Island, just as Daniel had said.
- Meanwhile, Sawyer and Juliet are being held captive and interrogated by Horace Goodspeed, Stuart Radzinsky, and Phil. Radzinsky quickly takes control of the situation, going so far as to even vocalize his position of power, saying that Horace doesn't have the "stomach for what happens next." Man...I'm really starting to feel sorry for Horace; I feel like he may have been one of the true innocent victims of the Purge... Radzinsky repeatedly beats Sawyer, demanding answers, specifically where the Hostiles are. After Phil goes so far as to punch Juliet in the face, Sawyer eventually caves in and draws a map to where the Hostiles are in exchange for the promise of Juliet and he being given safe passage off of the Island with the rest of the fleeing Dharma folks aboard the sub.
- Out in the jungle, Kate and Jack debate the validity and plausibility of Daniel's theory when he suddenly gets shot. Jack and Kate begin to retreat but are captured by two Hostiles on horseback, one of which is middle-aged Widmore, and Jack totally gets the crap owned out of his face...ouch... Jack admits that he and Kate were with Daniel, and Jack and Kate are brought into Eloise's tent. Eloise comes in to ask them some questions and, after some explanation by Jack, believes in his story; she understands that she did, in fact, just shoot her son from the future and decides that it is important that they follow through with her late son's plan and detonate the hydrogen bomb.
- Richard leaves with Eloise and Jack and Kate; they make their way to a pond where there is a secret underwater passage which leads into "The Tunnels." Before heading in, Kate decides she can't go any further. Eloise insists that Kate cannot leave, having acquired knowledge of the Tunnels, etc., but Kate starts to walk off anyway. Right before she's about to get capped by some other Hostile with them, a shot rings out from the forest, shooting said Hostile. And who else was behind this little attack other than Sayid? Richard asks Eloise privately what they're doing seeing as one of their people was just killed. Meanwhile, the other group comprised of Jack, Kate, and Sayid is having a little discussion of their own. Sayid agrees to Jack's plan, whereas Kate still maintains her position and this time leaves for good, but not before making a point to compare Jack to Locke right in Jack's face. Ouch...
- Richard, Jack, Sayid, and Eloise make their way down through the pond and up into the Tunnels. After some walking they come to Jughead, the hydrogen bomb which the Hostiles buried in obedience to Daniel, who commanded them to do so back in 1954.
- Back at the Barracks area, Sawyer and Juliet board the Dharma sub to travel back to the mainland and presumably be done with the Island forever. Sawyer reconnects with Juliet but then, suddenly, major buzzkill: Kate drops on in. Wow...fail... Apparently the Dharma Initiative didn't want to have anything to do with this troublemaker either... Yikes...
- FINALLY, let's recall what went down in present time, 2008: Locke meets up again with his people, finally after all this time... Locke informs Richard that the reason he seems different is because now he has a purpose. Sun takes an opportunity to confront Richard, inquiring of him if he has ever seen those of her friends pictured in the Dharma Initiative new recruits photo from 1974. He responds yes, he has, and that he watched them all die. Yikes...
- Locke takes Richard and Ben on a little journey that very night so that Richard can come talk to time-jumping Locke and take the bullet out of his leg, as well as tell himself from the past (err, future...) that he's going to have to die. I love how Richard was like, "Well, I'm glad that didn't have to happen," and Locke's just like, "Well, actually, Richard it did," right as he looked at Ben, as if just to say, "Douche." Richard follows Locke's instructions and relays all the information to time-jumping Locke. Meanwhile, Ben asks Locke how he could have known that it was this night in particular that Richard came out of the jungle and talked to him. Locke responds that the Island told him, and continues to rub it in Ben's face.
- The three return to the camp, where Locke informs the entire camp that they'll be taking a group trip to see Jacob, this man who they've apparently been taking orders from for some time but have never meant. Locke reassures Sun that Jacob will know what to do for them to reunite with their friends. On the way to Jacob's cabin, however, with Richard leading the way, Locke reveals to Ben his true purpose for wanting to go to the cabin: "So I can kill him." LOST
Story/Narrative - I loved how the focus on this episode, as the title "Follow the Leader" would seem to suggest, is all about people following their respective leaders, even when they're completely unsure as to whether they know what the hell they're doing or not. Obviously the two main examples of this in this episode were Jack and Locke... And not to say that Locke has by any means completely switched from man of faith to man of science, but it's pretty interesting that while Jack has completely switched from man of science to man of faith as he begins to trust in the Island's will and in his own destiny, Locke has in a small way accepted a man of science sort of view in that he wants to see for himself this Jacob and validate his authority in his own mind. Interesting...
Some refuse to follow their leaders in this episode, however: Kate decides she can no longer follow Jack -- he's simply become too crazy for her to handle, and she's specifically frustrated by all the Locke she's beginning to see in him... I definitely feel like this conversation's not over, though, and I'd be willing to guess that we'll be seeing more of Jack and Kate in the finale. Will she trust him and support his decision in the end?? What do you think?
The real, underlying point of tension that's going on between Jack and Kate right now, though, is their differing viewpoints on Daniel's rationale that the future can and should, in fact, be changed. While Kate sees all the good in what's happened after the crash -- Rose's cancer being cured, Locke no longer being a paraplegic, Charlie overcoming his heroine addiction, *cough* her not having to go to jail *cough*, and finally, her and Jack meeting and their subsequent on-again-off-again relationship over the past few years -- Jack sees all the anguish that came as a result of it... And it's not just that Jack is remorseful in regards to their relationship, having been hurt time and time again by Kate. Jack is still a fix-things-up-right kind of guy -- that's simply his personality -- and if he has a chance to eliminate the hundreds of innocent deaths that came as a result of the crash and those deaths which followed it on the Island, he's gonna take it. This is where he and Kate do not see eye-to-eye.
Luckily for Jack, not everyone is against him, though. Yes, I'm referring to Sayid. I loved his logic: "Well, if this works, you might just save us all. And if it doesn't?...at least you'll put us out of our misery." haha Beautiful.
Moving on to the other spectrum of things on the Island in the present, 2008, let me start off by saying that I have no doubt that that screenshot of the ship in the bottle that Richard was constructing was important... However, rather than it simply being a reference to Richard being a direct descendant from the Black Rock (which I'm not opposed to at all...), I'm thinking it might be more of a symbolic image of Richard -- an idea which I read about somewhere -- but more on that later!...
Sticking with Richard, I thought it was pretty sweet how they connected that scene with him finding a confused, time-jumping Locke in the jungle to now. Finally that conversation makes sense!!
Locke: "How did you know there was a bullet in my leg, Richard?"
Richard: "Because you told me there was, John."
Locke: "No...no. No, I didn't."
Richard: "Well...you will."
Beautiful. :)
Ben's one line to Richard was particularly amazing, too. After Locke invites the entire group of Others to go with him to go see Jacob, Richard turns to Ben confidentially and says, "I'm starting to think John Locke is going to be trouble," to which Ben replies, "Why do you think I tried to kill him?" haha He sounded so ridiculously serious!! haha I loved it..
And now a few odds and ends narrative-wise (I know, I know.. But this episode was just packed with good stuff!): First, let's talk about Horace and Eloise's relationship. "[Widmore] and Eloise are...well, let's just say love can be complicated." Those were Richard's exact words to Jack/Kate. I definitely think now that Widmore was the father of Eloise's son Daniel and that she is pregnant with said child right now during the timeline we're watching in 1977. If you noticed, during their conversation which we could hear very little of, Widmore subtely places his hand on Eloise's stomach and seems to want her to stay and not go with Richard and the two time-traveling intruders to the Tunnels...but she does anyway.
Another little thing: I was surprised at Sawyer. He's been so self-sacrificial for a while now, notably since the Season 4 finale, but now he suddenly seems to have completely sold out his friends, Jack and Kate. I mean, he drew a map for Radzinsky that would lead him to the Hostiles to wage his war, no doubt, knowing full well that Jack and Kate were probably with them by that point... Wow...harsh... My guess is that Kate will realize this and do something to disrupt the submarine's trip back, probably pissing off Sawyer... Or maybe Sawyer has known in his mind all along what his plan is and he hasn't really intended to abandon all his friends as it would appear... We'll see, I suppose.. What do you think about this? 5
LOST Theory/Mythology - So, we did gain some incredibly small measure of insight as to Richard's role: He's a "sort of advisor," according to Ben, a job which he has had "for a very, very long time," also according to Ben... Here's what I'm thinking: Richard has been promised and is holding down the fort, protecting the Island, until the arrival of this one, special leader -- yep, you guessed it: Locke. The reason I think Richard is so uneasy about Locke's decision to go see Jacob, bringing along freaking everyone with him, is because it is such a groundbreaking action, and one which Richard clearly did not expect. I think he's willing to go along with it, though, because he's known that this leader, once he arrived, would be so unpredictable in nature and would make some definite changes, ones that since he made them would be right... I think Richard's still just blown away at this substantial and non-customary of an action on Locke's part, though... We'll see how his faith in Locke plays out in the finale.
And in regards to the ship in the bottle image, I think Richard's simply been given the role of waiting on the Island for this person to come along and has been doing so for a veeerry long time. So then, he, in a sense, is sort of the ship trapped in the bottle. His state of existence is seemingly impossible -- he doesn't age -- just as it would seem that there is no way that a model ship could sit inside of a bottle. Plus, he's confined to this small space, and it is out of his power to leave... I think Richard is weary of his role, of his position, and of his life.
Staying on the topic of Richard, he said that he "watched them all die," Jack, Kate, Hugo... Here's what I'm thinking, and this is my theory regarding the major death: I bet Jack will finally fulfill his destiny in accordance with the Island, and, as a variable, act out, dying himself as a sacrifice for the rest of those who would have died alongside him in the Incident had he simply sat back and watched things unfold. Yes, this would be huge. Yes, it would groundbreaking.
...But you have to admit, it would be so undeniably epic... I'm willing to predict this over Juliet's death in the finale; let's see if I'm right... But tell me: Which major character do you think will die?
Moving on, I think it's important to take note that there is an extensive network of underground tunnels throughout the Island, it would seem...no doubt constructed by its original inhabitants... And it's interesting that the bomb is currently being stored under the Dharma Initiative Barracks... Is that simply coincidence?
Beyond that, I'm sure we'll find out how the bomb was brought down into the Tunnels in the finale; I can safely say that I have no idea how it happened so I won't even try to speculate...
Oh, and finally, it was cool to see Dr. Pierre Chang launching into action and taking it upon himself to issue the departure of all the non-essential members of the Dharma Initiative off of the Island. I especially loved the shot of Charlotte and her mom getting into one of the vans...good closure there... 4
BAMF moments - Sayid FINALLY came back, thank goodness, and in typical Sayid bamf style! What a win. His hidden attack and subsequent appearance alone merits this section a 3. :P
Also, not that it's "bamf," per say, but HOLY COW. Radzinsky is a freaking spaz!! I've always felt that way but he completely lost it when he was interrogating Sawyer. Wow...
Oh, and in anticipation of the finale, you can be sure that Sawyer will be true to his word: He's totally gonna kill Phil...and you know it'll be bamf...so I suppose this is more of a bamf prehash/prediction. ;) haha 3
Overall Score - (5 + 4 + 3)/(3) = 4
